Concept: Identity

Definition: (noun) the fact of being who or what a person or thing is.

Related Terms: Identity politics, intersectionality, elite capture

Description: The term identity has been one of the most contested and misunderstood in recent years. Both in scholarly and in popular understandings of the term, identity is a political category that can be polarizing and empowering at the same time. Many social movements, particularly in the United States, began as ways of reclaiming identities (such as that of African-Americans and women) that had been marginalized or silenced altogether. Waves of immigrants, from the Chinese to Eastern European Jews to Asians came to inhabit spaces—physical and psychological—based on their ethnic identities. Yet in reality, identity is hardly immutable.

In Stuart Hall’s memoir, Familiar Stranger: A Life between Two Islands (2017), the Jamaican-born British cultural theorist asserts that “no identities survive the diasporic process intact and unchanged, or maintain their connections with their past undisturbed.”¹ Here, the experience of migration is inflected by Hall’s encounter with postcolonial Britain, where diasporic identity serves as a space of anti-colonial resistance. In thinking of identity in relation to processes of migration, we may find alignment with Hall’s observation that rather than “a set of fixed attributes […] a singular, complete, finished state of being,” identity is instead a “constantly shifting process of positioning […] a never-completed process of becoming.”²

Contemporary intersectional understandings of identity as racialized, gendered, sexed, and classed, for instance, are profound overlapping elements of migrant identity. Such ideas are often found categorized under the contested label of “identity politics.” While derided by right-wing politicians in the same manner as the term “political correctness,” contemporary uses of “identity politics” by the left (and often on social media) diverge significantly from its origins with the Combahee River Collective. As a queer Black feminist collective, their 1977 manifesto outlined identity politics as an approach favoring diverse coalitional organizing.³ The mediated identity of the migrant, then, is necessarily viewed through this prism of intersectional, inter-causal relations.

Some of the most provocative immigrant novels and films probe questions of identity in specific communities. British writer Hanif Kureishi has critiqued and satirized the inter-generational gap between “purist” and “flexible” notions of identity in My Son the Fanatic (1994), and explored cross-cultural dynamics during most of his long and prolific literary career. 

S.C. & J.Y. 2024

 

Notes

¹ Stuart Hall, Familiar Stranger: A Life between Two Islands (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2017), 144.

² Hall, Familiar Stranger, 16

³ Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò, Elite Capture: How the Powerful Took Over Identity Politics (and Everything Else) (Chicago, IL: Haymarket Books), 11–12.

Related entries

Room To Breathe 2021-2022

January 25, 2022

Open the door, put down your suitcase, take off your coat, let the outside world fade away. This is where it begins. A room that… Read more

List of novels on migration (2020s)

January 3, 2022

Below is a gathered list of novels from the 2020s that touch upon themes of migration. We Are Not from Here by Jenny Torres Sanchez2020Migrations… Read more

List of novels on migration (2010s)

January 2, 2022

Below is a gathered list of novels from the 2010s that touch upon themes of migration. Secret Daughter by Shilpi Somaya Gowda2010Girls in Translation by… Read more

List of novels on migration (2000s)

January 2, 2022

Below is a gathered list of novels from the 2000s that touch upon themes of migration. The Vision of Emma Blau by Ursula Hegi2000Middlesex by… Read more

List of novels on migration (1990s)

January 2, 2022

Below is a gathered list of novels from the 1990s that touch upon themes of migration. Ruby by Rosa Guy1991The Inscrutable Americans by Anurag Mathur1991Dreaming… Read more

A Road to Oxford (2020)

November 15, 2021

After escaping from Syria in 2018, the English literature teacher Rawan has found his new home in Oxford, UK. In this short movie, he takes… Read more

Manus (2019)

November 15, 2021

This very poetic film offers an unedited insight into the hundreds of refugees and asylum seekers captivated offshore by the Australian Federal Government on Manus… Read more

The Chinese Exclusion Act – PBS (2018)

November 15, 2021

Directed by Ric Burns, The Chinese Exclusion Act was the first legislation that prevented an entire ethnic group from migrating to the U.S. Steeplechase’s documentary… Read more

Children of Syria (2016)

November 15, 2021

Some 6.7 million people — more than a quarter of the global refugee population — have fled brutal violence in Syria, the report said. This… Read more

The Good Postman (2016)

November 15, 2021

Directed by  Tonislav Hristov, this film follows Ivan, the local postman in a quiet Bulgarian community on the Turkish border, as he decides to run… Read more

Minari (2020)

November 15, 2021

MINARI by Lee Isaac Chung, USA 2020: A Korean American family moves to an Arkansas farm in search of its own American dream. Amidst the… Read more

Richard Blanco: How to Love a Country

November 29, 2020

The Cuban American civil engineer turned writer, Richard Blanco, straddles the many ways a sense of place merges with human emotion to make home and… Read more

Immigrant Art: A new perspective on the U.S. melting pot

August 26, 2020

By Guillermina Zabala Guillermina Zabala is a multidisciplinary artist and educator whose art examines the intersection between the individual and their social-political-cultural environment. Her works… Read more

Article: Emilie Cheyroux, Immigrant consumption and cultural visibility in documentary films by and about Latinos (2018)

November 11, 2019

Abstract: “This article analyzes two short documentaries showed at Cine Las Americas International Film Festival (Austin, Texas) and the way they discuss the symbolic meaning as well… Read more

Phones are now indispensable for refugees

December 6, 2017

SOMETIMES Hekmatullah, a 32-year-old Afghan, has to choose between food and connectivity. “I need to stay in touch with my wife back home,” he says,… Read more

The refugee crisis captured in haunting detail using infrared cameras

December 5, 2017

The Irish artist spent two years capturing the journeys of migrants into Europe using the camera, which can detect a human body from 30km and identify an… Read more

List of academic conferences on migration (2016-2017)

December 3, 2017

2016–17 “MIGRATION AND COMMUNICATION FLOWS: RETHINKING BORDERS, CONFLICT AND IDENTITY THROUGH THE DIGITAL” November 2-3 2017 – Bilbao, Spain “We are faced with a crisis… Read more

List of academic conferences on migration (2013-2015)

December 3, 2016

2015 “MIGRATION, MEDIA AND INTERCULTURAL DIALOGUE,” 25-26 NOVEMBER 2015, UNITED NATIONS UNIVERSITY, BARCELONA “TRANSIENT MIGRATION IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC: IDENTITIES, SOCIAL NETWORKS AND MEDIA,” 12 NOVEMBER… Read more

List of academic articles on migration (1981 to 2016)

December 3, 2016

2011-2016 Scott Blinder and William L. Allen. “Constructing Immigrants: Portrayals of Migrant Groups in British National Newspapers, 2010–2012.” International Migration Review. Spring 2016. Shepard, Mark. “Minor Urbanism: Everyday Entanglements… Read more

List of academic books on migration (1890s to 2012)

December 3, 2016

2011-12 CELIK, IPEK A. IN PERMANENT CRISIS: ETHNICITY IN CONTEMPORARY EUROPEAN MEDIA AND CINEMA. ANN ARBOR: UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN PRESS, 2015. MARTIN, Susan. A NATION OF IMMIGRANTS.… Read more

Article: George Lipsitz, The Meaning of Memory (1986)

November 3, 2016

American Studies scholar George Lipsitz’s article The Meaning of Memory: Family, Class, and Ethnicity in Early Network Television Programs (1986) examines how the “historical specificity… Read more

Article: Edward Said, Between Worlds (1998)

November 3, 2016

Edward Said makes sense of his life. “The day in early September 1951 when my mother and father deposited me at the gates of that… Read more

Jesse Chun’s ‘On Paper’

October 17, 2016

On Paper: Visual Artist Jesse Chun explores visual rhetoric involved in identity and mobility through an appropriation and transformation of the familiar marks contained in… Read more

Comic: Myanmar’s Rohingya Refugees

August 2, 2016

Author/illustrator Erik Thurman is an award-nominated creator who specializes in long-form comics journalism and nonfiction comics about current events. On August 1st, 2016, the political… Read more

Emigration Museum in Gdynia, Poland

July 14, 2016

“The history of departures from the Polish lands is hundreds of years old. People traveled to different parts of the world for sustenance, in search… Read more

The Value of Knitting for an Afghan Refugee

April 21, 2016

The short documentary Stitches is the story of a man who finds peace in knitting —after establishing a life in exile as an Afghan refugee… Read more

Syrian Refugees Recreate Destroyed Monuments to Always Remember Their Culturally Rich Architecture

March 4, 2016

“From a vantage point here in Za’atari, a group of Syrian artists have taken it upon themselves to recreate miniature models of the monuments that… Read more

Architecture and Migration: Mosques in Germany

March 3, 2016

The earliest mosque-style building in Germany is the “Red Mosque” at Schwetzingen, built in 1779-1791 by a French architct for the Prince Elector of the… Read more

Songs of the Syrian Refugees

March 1, 2016

“With his brow furrowed in concentration, Abu Abdullah rhythmically strums his oud, exploring the core of a melancholic melody. Mohamad Isa Almaziodi’s robust and melismatic… Read more

Marvel Comics’ secret weapon is a woman named Sana Amanat

February 28, 2016

On the last day of New York Comic Con, Sana Amanat begins the annual Women of Marvel panel with what is now a yearly tradition.… Read more

Greece’s Cemetery for Unknown Migrant Dead

February 16, 2016

From Reuters: “The marble plaques in this makeshift cemetery on the Greek island of Lesbos mark the graves of unknown refugees and migrants. Many of… Read more

America and Australia Rooms

December 7, 2015

America and Australia Rooms Institute of Migration, Finland Permanent Collection “America Room: What made people to move across the Atlantic Ocean? What was it like to… Read more

A Migrant’s Tale

November 23, 2015

From the artist’s website: “In 2008 I was carrying out fieldwork among a group of Egyptian immigrants in Milano, Italy, as part of my MA dissertation.… Read more

Shelbyville Multimedia: New Neighbors Give Thanks

November 23, 2015

“Shelbyville Multimedia introduces you to the cast of Welcome to Shelbyville, a handful of straight-talking people in rural Tennessee who are taking immigration into their… Read more

Stories from a Vanished Homeland

November 2, 2015

  Read more

Interactive learning resource: Language of Belonging (2010)

October 20, 2015

Language of Belonging is a multi-platform education resource based on the ground breaking Indigenous animation Wadu Matyidi.  Designed specifically for Primary-aged students, this diverse learning program explores… Read more

Pidgin, patois, slang, dialect, creole — English has more forms than you might expect

October 18, 2015

There are probably as many terms for different kinds of English vernacular as there are vernaculars themselves: pidgin, patois, slang, creole dialect and so on. [From Public… Read more

A Sri Lankan Girl Living in Lebanon Isn’t Really a Citizen of Either Country

October 18, 2015

Rainey is 13, her hair is tied back in a long ponytail. One of her favorite foods is tabbouleh, served on top of rice. She was… Read more

On Migration, Identity, and Borders

October 18, 2015

Gerald Machona is a Zimbabwean born visual artist, whose work engages with issues of migration, deeply investigating the social terrains where identity, space, social hierarchies… Read more

The Oakland Museum of California’s Who is Oakland? Exhibit

October 18, 2015

“Oakland is a city in flux. As people from San Francisco and elsewhere migrate to Oakland in hordes, the physical and social architecture seems to… Read more

Platanos Y Collard Greens

October 18, 2015

Written by David Lamb, directed by Summer Hill Seven and currently staged by Doni Comas, Platanos Y Collard Greens debuted to sold-out audiences on June… Read more

Hagia Sophia: Political and Religious Symbolism in Stones and Spolia

October 11, 2015

There has not been “an incident in Byzantine history with which the church of St. Sophia is not associated.”[1]  Hagia Sophia represents the very essence… Read more

Swiss Ban Building of Minarets on Mosques

October 11, 2015

In a vote that displayed a widespread anxiety about Islam and undermined the country’s reputation for religious tolerance, the Swiss on Sunday overwhelmingly imposed a… Read more

The State of Arizona (2014)

March 17, 2015

Through powerful footage and intimate access, THE STATE OF ARIZONA focuses on the controversial “papers please” law, SB1070. The feature-length, verité documentary interweaves the volatile… Read more

Death by Hanging (1968)

March 17, 2015

A clinically presented series of stark white, unembellished placards illustrates the sobering statistical data for the overwhelming public sentiment against the abolition of the death… Read more

Reminiscences of a journey to Lithuania (1972)

March 17, 2015

Reminiscences of a journey to Lithuania (1972) After a twenty-seven year absence, Adolfas and his brother Jonas returned to their birthplace in Lithuania. They had… Read more

La promesse (1996)

March 17, 2015

La promesse is the breakthrough feature from Luc and Jean-Pierre Dardenne, who would go on to become a force in world filmmaking. The brothers brought… Read more

Stranger Than Paradise (1984)

February 13, 2015

Stranger Than Paradise (1984) Rootless Hungarian immigrant Willie (John Lurie), his pal Eddie (Richard Edson), and visiting sixteen-year-old cousin Eva (Eszter Balint) always manage to… Read more

My American Dream, How Democracy Works Now (2010)

February 13, 2015

How Democracy Works Now: Twelve Stories (2010) The documentary contains multiple, in-depth portraits that are weaved together to illustrate the full-blown social movement. It offers… Read more

The House of Sand and Fog (2003)

February 13, 2015

The House of Sand and Fog (2003) Academy Award winners Ben Kingsley (Gandhi) and Jennifer Connelly (A Beautiful Mind) deliver stunning performances as two strangers… Read more

The Godfather Part II (1974)

February 13, 2015

The Godfather Part II (1974) Francis Ford Coppola took some of the deep background from the life of Mafia chief Vito Corleone–the patriarch of Mario… Read more

Fast Food Nation (2006)

February 13, 2015

Fast Food Nation (2006) Don Henderson (Greg Kinnear)-a marketing executive at Mickey’s Fast Food Restaurant chain, home of “The Big One”-has a problem. Contaminated meat… Read more

Man Push Cart (2005)

February 13, 2015

Man Push Cart (2005) Every night while the city sleeps, Ahmad, a former rock star in his native Pakistan, drags his heavy cart along the… Read more